Marketing defines relevance
Agree on the service interest, location and recency that make a message useful. Document exclusions, including communication preferences and customers already in an active conversation.
A useful audience starts with more than a contact list. It depends on what your teams know, where that information lives, and whether the next person can act on it.
First-party data is information your organisation collects directly through its own customer interactions. Its value depends on consistent definitions, not simply the number of fields collected.
Agree on the service interest, location and recency that make a message useful. Document exclusions, including communication preferences and customers already in an active conversation.
Ask frontline teams which details distinguish a real opportunity from a poor fit. Establish who records changes when a customer moves, switches location or changes their needs.
Define what happens when a campaign produces an enquiry. Record the outcome in a shared place so the next audience is not built on an outdated assumption.
Bring a real use case to a CRM evaluation: for example, a relevant service reminder for customers of a particular location. Ask the team to trace the data from its source through to follow-up.
Explore how duplicate records are found and resolved, especially when a customer has interacted with more than one location. Decide who can correct the record.
Check whether teams can build and review groups using meaningful fields such as service history, location and stated interests. Ask how a group changes when a record is updated.
Examine where communication preferences are recorded and how they are applied when an audience is prepared. Include a check for customers who should not receive a particular message.
Discuss what central marketing and each location need to see or edit. Evaluate whether access can be shaped around those responsibilities without losing the context of a shared customer.
Trace what a location would see when someone responds. Look for a clear way to identify the audience, understand the enquiry and record its outcome for future planning.
A central campaign may reach the right person but still create friction if the receiving location does not know why that person was contacted or who should respond.
Agree on the audience definition, the intended response and the location responsible for enquiries. Give local teams a concise explanation of the message and its exclusions.
Review whether enquiries reached the right team and whether the audience matched the offer. Feed recurring misroutes and missing information back into the next audience definition.
The strongest evaluation question is not only “Can we make this audience?” It is also “Can every team understand why someone is in it, act on a response and keep the record useful?” Use that shared test to guide your CRM selection discussion.
Return to the evaluation criteria ↑